Ex Parte Steiner et al - Page 2




                        1.    Claims 37-72 are pending on appeal (Appeal Brief,                          
            Paper 11, page 2 and Appendix).                                                              
                        2.    According to applicants, "[f]or the purpose of                             
            this appeal only, the claims stand or fall together for each                                 
            ground of rejection ***" (Appeal Brief, page 2).                                             
                        3.    Pursuant to 37 CFR § 1.192(c)(7)(2002), we                                 
            select independent claim 37 and decide the appeal solely on the                              
            basis of claim 37.                                                                           
                        4.    Claim 37 reads as follows:                                                 
                  A pharmaceutical composition which comprises:                                          
                        (i) an effective amount of a heterocyclic compound                               
                              having one nitrogen heteroatom, which has a                                
                              substituent attached to said nitrogen [hetero]atom                         
                              of the heterocyclic ring,2 which is )C(W))C)(Y)),                          
                                     wherein W and Y are independently                                   
                              selected from the group consisting of O [oxygen],                          
                              S [sulfur], CH2, and H2,                                                   
                                     and which compound is additionally                                  
                              substituted with a thioester or ketone substituent                         
                              attached to any carbon atom of the heterocyclic                            
                              ring,3                                                                     
                                     provided that said thioester or ketone                              
                              substituent is not an N-oxide of said thioester or                         
                              ketone substituent; and                                                    
                  (ii) a pharmaceutically acceptable carrier.                                            



            2   Strictly speaking, there is no antecedent for the language "the                          
            heterocyclic ring".  Moreover, the language would appear to be unnecessary                   
            since "said nitrogen [hetero]atom" necessarily refers to "one nitrogen                       
            heteroatom".                                                                                 
            3   With respect to the language "the heterocyclic ring", see n.2.                           
                                                 - 2 -                                                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007