Ex Parte Dillard - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2003-1572                                                        
          Application No. 09/661,747                                                  

               Kellogg, the examiner’s primary reference, pertains to a               
          method and apparatus for reducing undesirable fluid accumulations           
          in a body area by compressing a multiplicity of particles against a         
          swollen body area to                                                        
               thereby creat[e] a network of relatively narrow low                    
               pressure channels and a relatively large high pressure                 
               surface area where the network of channels intersects the              
               high pressure surface area, and thereby increases the                  
               rate of drainage of the interstitial fluid through the                 
               channels and from the affected body area.  [Column 3,                  
               lines 43-49.]                                                          
               To this end, Kellogg provides an enclosure of porous or                
          breathing fabric to organize and carry the particles.  The                  
          particles may include “mixtures of particles of varying                     
          characteristics, such as chemical composition, resiliency, density,         
          shape, and/or size” (column 5, lines 58-60).  In keeping with               
          Kellogg’s objective, the particles may be made of high resiliency,          
          low density foam plastic, such as 100% shredded medical grade               
          polyurethane foam (column 8, lines 2-6).                                    
               Chuang is directed to a multi-function pillow.  As set forth           
          in the “Background” section of Chuang’s specification, although it          
          was known in the art at the time of Chuang’s invention to use               
          buckwheat hulls as a filler for pillows in order to take advantage          
          for their excellent resilience strength and ability to provide              
          ventilation, such pillows did not meet with much market acceptance.         
                                          5                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007