Ex Parte Reynolds - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2004-0356                                                        
          Application 09/811,993                                                      

          information (22) disposed in the carrier frame; and a support               
          bracket (18) interposed between the clamp (82) and the carrier              
          frame (16), the support bracket removably and deflectably holding           
          the carrier frame so that the frame normally cantilevers                    
          transversely into the shopping aisle.  As recognized by the                 
          examiner, what the advertising display apparatus of Boggess lacks           
          relative to appellant’s claimed advertising display assembly is             
          any teaching of or reference to providing a source of                       
          illumination (i.e., lights) on the display apparatus.                       

          To account for this difference, the examiner looks to                       
          Sernovitz, noting that this patent shows an illuminated display             
          device that includes a plurality of lights (25) thereon                     
          surrounding a display area and a source of power (e.g., battery             
          26) carried by the display device.  Sernovitz indicates (col. 1,            
          lines 5-8) that the display device therein is for use on “display           
          racks, shelving or the like for retail merchandise.”  While                 
          Sernovitz shows one possible mounting means for the display                 
          apparatus as a pair of tines (55), it is expressly indicated in             
          column 3, lines 34-36, that alternative supporting means may be             
          provided, “such as adhesive mounting means . . ., easel means,              
          hanging means and the like.”  Sernovitz notes that the lights               
                                          6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007