Ex Parte O'Donnell et al - Page 2



             Appeal No. 2004-0421                                                                                    
             Application No. 09/749,923                                                                              
                                                 BACKGROUND                                                          
                    Appellants’ invention is directed to a component of semiconductor processing                     
             equipment that comprises a fullerene coating.  According to Appellants, semiconductor                   
             processing equipment includes components that are exposed to highly corrosive plasma                    
             during semiconductor processing.  (Brief, p. 2).  Claims 12 and 22 which are                            
             representative of the invention are reproduced below:                                                   
                    12.   A component of semiconductor processing equipment comprising:                              
                    (a) a surface;                                                                                   
                    (b) an optional intermediate coating on said surface;                                            
                    (c) an optional second intermediate coating on said first intermediate                           
                    coating or on said surface; and                                                                  
                    (d) a fullerene containing coating on said component that forms an outer                         
                    corrosion resistant surface.                                                                     
                    22.  A component of semiconductor processing equipment having at least                           
                    one surface exposed to plasma in the equipment, the component                                    
                    comprising a fullerene containing material forming a surface exposed to                          
                    plasma in the equipment.                                                                         
                                               CITED PRIOR ART                                                       
                    As evidence of unpatentability, the Examiner relies on the following prior art:                  
             Fagan                                   5,382,719                    Jan.  17, 1995                     
             Holtkamp                                5,704,613                    Jan.  06, 1998                     
             Appellants’ admission of the prior art in the specification, page 2, third paragraph of the             
             disclosure.                                                                                             

                                                         -2-                                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007