Ex Parte Beck - Page 15


         Appeal No. 2004-1043                                                       
         Application No. 09/960,907                                                 

                   (b) Providing a plurality of non-consumable anodes               
              and cathodes disposed vertically in the electrolyte;                  
                   (c) Heating the cell up to operating                             
              temperature and completely melting the                                
              electrolyte; and                                                      
                   (d) Passing an electric current through the anodes               
              and through the electrolyte to the cathodes, depositing               
              aluminum on the cathodes and generating oxygen bubbles that           
              stir the electrolyte.                                                 
                   Regarding claim 36, Beck discloses the use of an                 
              electrolyte temperature of 750°C (abstract).                          
                   Regarding claim 37, Beck discloses the use of alkali             
              metal fluorides in the bath including NaF (introduction).             
                   Regarding claim 40, Beck uses anodes and an anodic               
              liner made of Cu-Ni-Fe alloy (p. 359, col.1).                         
                   Regarding claim 41, Beck provides an example of a cell           
              operated at 0.5 A/cm2 (p. 359, col. 2).                               
                   Regarding claim 42, Beck discloses the use of titanium           
              diboride cathodes (abstract).                                         
                   Regarding claim 43, the anodes and cathode are                   
              disposed in an alternating relationship (fig. 10).                    
                   The method of Beck differs from the instant invention            
              because Beck does not disclose the following:                         
                        a. Adding solid electrolyte and alumina                     
                   to the cell, as recited in claim 35;                             
                        b. Placing a heater adjacent to the                         
                   bottom of the liner and adding heat to the                       
                   bottom until the electrolyte until it is                         
                   melted, as recited in claim 35; and                              
                        c. A plurality of anodes and a                              
                   plurality of cathodes, as recited in~clairn                      
                   43;                                                              



                                         15                                         



Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007