Ex Parte SHENKMAN - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2004-1179                                                         
          Application No. 09/127,284                                                   


          caller/customer of the interaction request (Abstract).  Walker               
          retrieves data specific to the customer (e.g., items ordered in              
          the past, dollar amounts of past customer orders, stored location            
          of the customer) (Abstract; column 3, line 64 through column 4,              
          line 8; column 6, lines 38 through 42).  Walker also retrieves               
          real-time variable data other than customer-specific data in the             
          form of pricing data (Abstract; column 2, lines 54 through 57;               
          column 5, lines 5 and 6).  To the extent that the disclosed and              
          claimed telephone communications system uses an algorithm to                 
          perform profit calculations, we find that the same type of system            
          disclosed by Walker would likewise use an algorithm to perform               
          calculations to derive economic/profit data based on the                     
          retrieved data (Abstract; column 3, lines 64 through 67; column              
          5, lines 54 through 56; column 6, lines 9 through 11).  We reach             
          such a conclusion because appellant’s disclosure assumes that                
          “anyone desiring to carry out the process would know of the                  
          equipment and techniques [(e.g., algorithms)] to be used, none               
          being specifically described.”  In re Fox, 471 F.2d 1405, 1407,              
          176 USPQ 340, 341 (CCPA 1973).  As indicated supra, Walker uses              
          the probable profitability calculation to automatically route the            
          calling customer to an available resource in the form of a                   
          location in the queue (Abstract; column 6, lines 9 through 19).              

                                          5                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007