Ex Parte Wheat et al - Page 6




         Appeal No. 2004-2027                                                       
         Application No. 09/670,189                                                 



              mixture of Ar/10 volume % HCl was flowed in an external               
              chloride generator through a hafnium bed at 430 ºC. to                
              form hafnium tetrachloride containing a small amount                  
              (e.g. less than 1 volume %) of zirconium tetrachloride.               
              The hafnium bed included a small concentration of                     
              zirconium, such as less, than 1 weight % Zr.                          
              Alternately, the coating gas mixture can be flowed                    
              through a cogenerator having a hafnium bed and a                      
              zirconium bed downstream of the hafnium bed to form                   
              coating gas mixture...  [Underscoring added.]                         
              Smith discloses “sintered cemented carbide bodies coated              
         with thin and extremely wear resistant surface layers.”  (Column           
         1, lines 6-8.)  Specifically, Smith teaches a method of making an          
         aluminum oxide-coated cemented carbide body, wherein: a cemented           
         carbide substrate is contacted with a gas containing an aluminum           
         halide and a reducing agent at high temperature; titanium,                 
         zirconium, and/or hafnium ions are added as dopants to the gas in          
         an amount of 0.03-0.5% of the total amount of supplied gas; and            
         the cemented carbide is coated with aluminum oxide, at least 85%           
         of which is in the kappa form.  (Column 2, lines 26-37.)                   
         According to Smith, the aluminum chloride may be provided in the           
         gas form by evaporation of the solid or liquid form.  (Column 5,           
         lines 18-21.)                                                              
              Basta ’963 discloses a CVD method in which a substrate                
         (e.g., nickel base superalloy) to be coated is supported in a              
         coating region of a reactor chamber and is heated to an elevated           
         reaction temperature.  (Column 3, lines 19-23.)  According to              
         Basta ’963, the method is especially useful for CVD aluminizing            

                                         6                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007