Ex Parte STURLA et al - Page 2


              Appeal No. 2004-2322                                                               Page 2                
              Application No. 09/385,412                                                                               

                     an organic solvent, wherein the weight ratio of the propellant to the organic                     
              solvent is greater than or equal to 1.5:1; and                                                           
                            (ii) the device is suitable for giving an initial flow rate of aerosol                     
              composition of less than or equal to 0.75 gram per second,                                               
                     wherein said at least one polycondensate is formed by an arrangement of blocks,                   
              this arrangement being obtained from:                                                                    
                     (1) at least one compound which contains at least two active hydrogen atoms per                   
              molecule;                                                                                                
                     (2) at least one diol containing at least one functional group chosen from acid                   
              radicals and salts thereof; and                                                                          
                     (3) at least one isocyanate chosen from di-and polyisocyanates.                                   

                     The examiner relies on the following references:                                                  
              Mougin et al. (Mougin)                   5,643,581                  Jul.  01, 1997                     
              Dunne et al. (Dunne)                     5,125,546                  Jun. 30, 1992                      

                     Claims 1-29 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as obvious in view of Mougin                     
              and Dunne.                                                                                               
                     We affirm.                                                                                        
                                                     Background                                                        
                     “Hair products for shaping and/or maintaining the hairstyle which are the most                    
              common on the cosmetics market are spray compositions comprising a solution . . . and                    
              one or more materials, generally polymer resins (also known as fixing materials), the                    
              function of which is to form welds between the hairs. . . .  The solution can be packaged,               
              for example, in a suitable aerosol container placed under pressure using a propellant.                   
              The construction and operation of such aerosol containers is well known to those skilled                 
              in the art.”  Specification, page 1.                                                                     








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007