Ex Parte Furst et al - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2005-0784                                                        
          Application No. 10/138,315                                                  
                    performing a 1st folding operation by folding the                 
               three regions so that the three regions overlap one                    
               another and adhered together as shown in figures 6-7,                  
               thereby forming 1st and 2nd  parallel fold lines (20,22)                
               which are transverse to the glue strips;                               
                    trimming “at the head and foot [i.e. first and                    
               second fold lines] of each booklet”.                                   
                    performing a 2nd folding operation by folding                     
               along scored lines (i.e. axis of the glue strip) to                    
               form interconnected booklets (col. 4 lines 10-68;                      
               figures 2,6-7).                                                        
                    Lyon, Jr. does not teach forming a compact booklet                
               by performing a 3rd folding operation, wherein this                    
               operation comprises folding a booklet one or more times                
               about one or more folding lines which are parallel to a                
               glue line.  However, it would have been obvious in the                 
               art to use the booklets of Lyon, Jr. as outserts for                   
               articles such as pharmaceutical products (i.e.                         
               information regarding a drug product printed thereon),                 
               because DeLise discloses using booklets, of similar                    
               structure to the one taught by Lyon, Jr., as outserts                  
               for articles such as pharmaceutical products (col. 1                   
               lines 12-40; figures 1 and 4).  Note: although it is                   
               preferred in Lyon, Jr. to use the inventive booklets as                
               self mailer, it would appear that booklets are not                     
               restrictively used for self-mailing products as                        
               evidence from the following passages: “This invention                  
               relates to an article containing multiple pages which                  
               is capable of being separated into multiple booklets or                
               pamphlets all of which booklets are of the same size                   
               and contain the same number of pages.  ...In this form                 
               my invention is readily adaptable for use as a self-                   
               mailer ....” (emphasis added; col. 1 lines 8-24).  It                  
               directly follows that, it would have been obvious in                   
               the art to fold a resultant booklet taught by Lyon, Jr.                
               for at least two or more times about folding lines that                
               are parallel to a glue line, because DeLise teaches                    
               folding a booklet two or more times about fold lines                   
               which are parallel to a bound end (28) to form a                       
               compact folded booklet so that it can readily be                       

                                          5                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007