Ex Parte Goldstein - Page 9



           Appeal No. 2005-0823                                                                        
           Application No. 10/300,895                                              Page 9              


            to a customer, reporting the issuance of the ticket to an                                  
            intermediate agent on Tuesday night, and imposing a fee for                                
            changes made after the issuance of the ticket has been reported.                           
            The examiner notes that IAH does not disclose that “the                                    
            prescribed rate minimizes the amount of time between issuance and                          
            reporting."  We consider the examiner’s statement to mean that                             
            IAH does not disclose reporting the issuance of the ticket by the                          
            following day.  To make up for this deficiency of IAH, the                                 
            examiner turns to Brice for a teaching of "the SABRE system which                          
            retrieves the reports from the intermediate agent as a batch                               
            process that can be scheduled to occur alternately on Monday at 1                          
            am, or daily, monthly or periodically."  The examiner notes that                           
            Brice also does not teach "the motivation more frequent                                    
            reporting."  The examiner's statement is not very clear.                                   
            However, we consider the examiner to be attempting to say that                             
            Brice also does not disclose reporting the issuance of the travel                          
            ticket by the following day.  To overcome the deficiencies of IAH                          
            and Brice, the examiner (answer, page 4) turns to IATA for a                               
            teaching of a "suggestion by Bruce Bishins, President of U.S.                              
            Travel Agency [sic] Registry" that “‘the airlines alleged that                             
            ARC would soon ‘enhance’ IAR to move the world to daily reporting                          






Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007