Ex Parte Hinds et al - Page 7


           Appeal No. 2005-1635                                                                      
           Application No. 09/782,036                                                                

           and/or Bradshaw, to form a laminated floor covering by using a                            
           conveyor belt to coat both sides of a textile sheet with                                  
           thermoplastic particles as required by the claims on appeal.                              
           On this record, we answer this question in the affirmative.                               
                 As indicated supra, Brinkmann, using its conveyor belt                              
           arrangement, produces a single-layer floor covering with                                  
           scattered thermoplastic power on a conveyor belt or a laminated                           
           floor covering with thermoplastic powder on a textile sheet.                              
           Although Brinkmann does not expressly teaches a laminated floor                           
           covering having both sides of the textile sheet coated with                               
           thermoplastic power, i.e., thermoplastic powder on and below the                          
           textile sheet on a conveyor belt, we find that Takeuchi teaches                           
           that laminated floor coverings can be produced by applying                                
           thermoplastic powder on one side of a textile sheet or both                               
           sides of a textile sheet.  See Takeuchi, Figures 1 and 2,                                 
           together column 7, lines 1-15, and column 10, lines 55-68 and                             
           column 3, lines 50-68.  We find that Takeuchi teaches that                                
           thermoplastic powder can be coated onto a textile sheet via,                              
           inter alia, a conveyor belt method.  See Examples 11, 12 and 13                           
           at column 10, line 55 to column 11, line 11.  We find that                                
           Takeuchi, for example, teaches (column 11, lines 7-11) that:                              



                                                 7                                                   


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007