Ex Parte Dunn et al - Page 4



            Appeal No. 2006-0360                                                                      
            Application No. 10/388,691                                                                
                  As to claim 26, the examiner points to Central Station 14 of                        
            Garfinkle for the teaching of maintaining on a server video content                       
            that may be served to a client device (referring to column 2, lines                       
            66-67) for transmitting a video from a server 14 to a client device                       
            (elements 18 and 24).  The examiner points to column 3, lines 27-                         
            30, of Garfinkle for a disclosure of receiving at the server a                            
            request from the client device (elements 18 and 24) to rent the                           
            video for a specified period of time.  The examiner further notes                         
            column 3, lines 37-39, for the user requesting how long to rent the                       
            video upon request.                                                                       

                  The examiner points to column 3, lines 39-40 of the reference                       
            for the rental time period being fixed (stored) at the server.                            
            Moreover, the examiner points to column 3, lines 12-26, and 30-48,                        
            of the reference for the teaching of transmitting the video content                       
            to the client device one or more times during the rental period.                          
            The examiner indicates column 4, lines 34-40, of Garfinkle for a                          
            teaching of determining that the rental period has expired, and                           
            further indicates column 4, lines 44-48, of the reference for the                         
            teaching of refusing to transmit the video content to the client                          
            device because the rental time period has expired.                                        



                                                  4                                                   



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007