Ex Parte Anthony et al - Page 9




              Appeal No. 2006-1413                                                                  Page 9                 
              Application No. 09/952,073                                                                                   


              services."  (Col. 1, ll. 14-18.)  "The use of the secure token device enables ISPs to tailor                 
              their service offerings and billing options to individual users.  The users may be offered                   
              different service options."  (Col. 4, ll. 42-44.)                                                            


                     Because Jaalinoja teaches ordering an electronic token that allows a wireless                         
              terminals access to an external network or access to local services, or DiGiorgio                            
              teaches ordering ISP-provided services for a user's "PDA, a personal computer (PC) or                        
              a workstation," (col. 5, ll. 47-48), we find that teachings from the prior art itself would                  
              have suggested ordering a service for an electronic device.                                                  


                                         B. BASING PROVISIONING ON ANSWERS                                                 
              The examiner finds that Jaalinoja teaches the following features:                                            
                     • prompting said user to answer a plurality of questions [paragraph                                   
                            0021i.e. WAP service is inherent];                                                             
                     • generating corresponding provisioning information for said network                                  
                            communication device within said electronic device based on                                    
                            answers given by said user in response to said plurality of                                    
                            questions [paragraphs 0021-24 i.e. generating a token according to                             
                            the received token request or to the WAP service][.]                                           
              (Examiner's Answer at 4-5.)  The appellants argue, "Paragraphs 0021-0024 of                                  
              Jaalinoja may provide the generation of a token according to a token request but                             
              certainly not based on answers given by a user in response to a series of questions                          
              during the order placement of the electronic device."  (App. Br. at 5.)                                      







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007