Ex Parte Westphal et al - Page 10



         Appeal No. 2006-1695                                                       
         Application No. 10/649,277                                                 
         According to appellants, Kuchta teaches away from the claimed              
         system which processes the images' original content before                 
         compression, selection, and storage to increase the number of              
         images capable of being stored in a memory device [brief, page             
         10].  As a result, appellants conclude that the cited prior art            
         does not teach nor suggest (1) selecting one compressed resultant          
         image from a plurality of compressed resultant images, and then            
         (2) placing each of the selected ones of the plurality of                  
         compressed, resultant images into memory as claimed [reply brief,          
         page 5].                                                                   
              The examiner argues that by storing Takagi's compressed               
         resultant images in accordance with Kuchta's method, reduced-size          
         preview images can be quickly displayed since it is unnecessary            
         to decompress the full-resolution version of the image [answer,            
         pages 17, 20, and 21].  The examiner further notes that because            
         Takagi's compressed resultant images that are displayed as a               
         group are already stored in memory prior to display, the combined          
         teachings of the cited prior art teaches that all of the selected          
         images have already been placed into a concatenation file (i.e.,           
         stored) when they are selected [answer, page 18].                          



                                         10                                         




Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007