Ex Parte Mitra et al - Page 9



         Appeal No. 2006-1729                                                       
         Application No. 10/107,628                                                 
                   compaction occurs.  In the commonly-used signature               
                   analysis [8] time compaction technique, the time                 
                   compaction ratio is typically several (> 3) orders.              
                   The row index of the test data matrix.  D is referred            
                   to as the space dimension since it corresponds to the            
                   output bits from different circuit nodes resulting from          
                   the application of a single input test pattern.  Thus,           
                   if Φ is such that C has its space dimension p < m, then          
                   space compaction occurs.  Using the quotient bit of              
                   MISRs [12], [37], parity [7], [27], and MINSRs [1], are          
                   known structures for performing space compaction.                
                        It is possible to have both time and space                  
                   compaction performed concurrently.  An example of such           
                   a compactor is the well-known MISR.                              

              With the above discussion in mind, we find that with regard           
         to representative claim 1, the Ivanov reference teaches a built-           
         in self-test (BIST) space compaction scheme wherein wide multi-            
         bit input streams are reduced to narrower output bit streams.              
         Particularly, as depicted in figure 4, Ivanov teaches a general            
         compaction case where an input test data matrix Dmxn is fed into a         
         programmable space compactor (PSC) to yield an output matrix Cpxq          
         where p and q are less than m and n respectively.  One of                  
         ordinary skill in the art would have duly recognized that                  
         Ivanov’s teaching of a PSC to transform the input matrix Dmxn into         
         an output matrix Cpxq of a reduced dimension amounts to the PSC            
         being characterized as a vector or a matrix (PSCxy) itself, as             
         required by the claim.  It is self-evident from the principles of          

                                         9                                          




Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007