Ex Parte Saranditis - Page 9

                   Appeal 2006-2171                                                                                                 
                   Application 10/840,715                                                                                           

                   CLAIMS 10, 11, 13 AND 26                                                                                         
                           Method claims 10 and 11 ultimately depend on claim 1.  Claim 10                                          
                   recites, in relevant part, that the “monitoring step” further includes “counting                                 
                   the number times said pump is operated within a predetermined period of                                          
                   time” (claim 10).  Claim 11, depends on claim 10 and further recites                                             
                   “communicating a warning if said number of times said pump is operated                                           
                   within a predetermined period of times exceeds a predetermined number”                                           
                   (claim 11).                                                                                                      
                           Claim 13 and claim 26 are independent apparatus claims.  Claim 13                                        
                   recites, in relevant part, that the apparatus has “a holding tank . . .                                          
                   exclusively receiving water collected by said containment vessel” and  “an                                       
                   electronic circuit for monitoring the rate of water collection in said holding                                   
                   tank, said electronic circuit comprising a counting circuit for determining the                                  
                   number of times said pump is operated during a predetermined period of                                           
                   time, and an alerting device for communicating a warning indication when                                         
                   said pump is operated a certain number of times within a predetermined                                           
                   period of time.”                                                                                                 
                           Claim 26 recites, in relevant part, similar features as claim 13, with                                   
                   the exception that the “holding tank” need not be “exclusively” for                                              
                   accumulating water from said containment vessel.  Specifically, claim 26                                         
                   recites, in relevant part, “a control unit, said control unit monitoring a rate of                               
                   water accumulation in said holding tank and generating a warning signal                                          
                   when said rate of water accumulation exceeds a predetermined rate; wherein                                       
                   said control unit monitors said rate of water accumulation in said holding                                       
                   tank based on the number of times said pump is operated during a                                                 
                   predetermined period of time.”                                                                                   

                                                                 9                                                                  

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013