Ex Parte Singer et al - Page 4


                    Appeal 2006-2836                                                                                                        
                    Application 09/923,673                                                                                                  

                    devices communicate with each other over the network.  The slave game                                                   
                    devices receive from the master game device commands and random data,                                                   
                    such as bingo patterns and bingo and keno numbers called by the game                                                    
                    operator.  Each slave game device sends to the master game device the local                                             
                    game status and accounting information.  The slave game devices execute in                                              
                    real time (play) concurrently a number of menu-selectable card and chance                                               
                    games, such as bingo, keno, poker, blackjack, and the like” (col. 1, ll. 43-                                            
                    53).  A slave game device can play simultaneously a number of independent                                               
                    and distinct games of the same type (col. 5, ll. 37-38).  The disclosed games                                           
                    include slots (col. 6, ll. 21-26).                                                                                      
                            There is no dispute as to whether Piechowiak would have fairly                                                  
                    suggested, to one of ordinary skill in the art, using multiple paylines in                                              
                    Gatley’s slot machine (Br. 8-9).                                                                                        
                            The Appellants argue that Itkis displays common event games such as                                             
                    bingo and keno on the screen of a dumb terminal, and does not disclose                                                  
                    displaying on the screen two independent slot machine games (Br. 9).  The                                               
                    dumb terminal referred to by the Appellants is what Itkis calls “an intelligent                                         
                    (smart) game terminal” comprising a microprocessor, a local data input and                                              
                    output device, and a transceiver (col. 2, ll. 57-62).  Itkis’ disclosures that the                                      
                    games are independent and distinct, the games include slots, and the slave                                              
                    game device can play simultaneously a number of games of the same type                                                  
                    (col. 5, ll. 37-38; col. 6, ll. 21-26) would have fairly suggested, to one of                                           
                    ordinary skill in the art, playing at least two independent and distinct slot                                           
                    games simultaneously on the same slave game device.  As with all of Itkis’                                              


                                                                     4                                                                      

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013