Ex Parte Beck et al - Page 2


               Appeal No.  2006-3250                                                  Page 2                
               Application No. 10/468,562                                                                   
                        b) passing the D-pantothenate-containing fermentation solution through              
                        an anion exchanger and thereby binding the D-pantothenic acid to the                
                        anion exchanger,                                                                    
                        c) removing the D-pantothenic acid from the anion exchanger by eluting              
                        the D-pantothenate bound to the anion exchanger in the form of calcium              
                        and/or magnesium D-pantothenate by a solution containing inorganic or               
                        organic calcium salts and/or magnesium salts, or eluting the bound                  
                        D-pantothenate in the form of free D-pantothenic acid using an HCl                  
                        solution,                                                                           
                        d) optionally adding calcium base and/or magnesium base to set the                  
                        free D-pantothenic acid-containing eluate to a pH of 3-10, a solution               
                        being obtained which contains calcium and/or magnesium pantothenate                 
                        and                                                                                 
                        e) subjecting the eluate or the solution containing calcium pantothenate            
                        and/or magnesium pantothenate to drying and/or formulation                          
                        wherein no free β-alanine and/or β-alanine salt is fed to the culture               
                        medium.                                                                             

                      The references relied upon by the Examiner are:                                       
               Hikichi et al. (Hikichi)  5,518,906   May 21, 1996                                           
               Binder et al. (Binder)  6,582,939   Jun. 24, 2003                                            
               Hoffman-La Roche & Co.  GB 562,267     Jun. 26, 1944                                         
               Baigori et al. (Baigori), “Isolation and Characterization of Bacillus subtilis Mutants       
               Blocked in the Synthesis of Pantothenic Acid,” J Bacteriology, Vol. 173,                     
               No. 13, pp. 4240-4242 (1991)                                                                 
               Sorokin et al. (Sorokin), “Sequence analysis of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome             
               region between the serA and kdg loci cloned in a yeast artificial chromosome,”               
               Microbiol., Vol. 142, pp. 2005-2016 (1996)                                                   

                                         GROUND OF REJECTION                                                
                      Claims 1 and 5-19 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as being                       
               unpatentable over the combination of Hikichi, Baigori, Binder and Hoffman-La                 
               Roche.                                                                                       





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013