Ex Parte Kane - Page 2



            Appeal 2006-3331                                                                               
            Application 10/829,797                                                                         


                                       SUMMARY OF DECISION                                                 
                  We AFFIRM and REMAND.                                                                    

                                           THE INVENTION                                                   
                  The Appellant’s claimed invention is to a method and apparatus for                       
            preventing check fraud.  Claim 1, reproduced below, is representative of the                   
            subject matter on appeal.                                                                      
                         1. A method for preventing check fraud, the method                                
                         comprising the steps of:                                                          
                               establishing personal identification access                                 
                         information for a checking account;                                               
                               transmitting the checking account information and                           
                         the personal identification access information over an                            
                         electronic network from a first location to an independent                        
                         third party service provider;                                                     
                               comparing the transmitted information with stored                           
                         checking account information and stored personal                                  
                         identification access information at the service provider                         
                         for verification; and                                                             
                               transmitting a verification signal over an electronic                       
                         network from the service provider to the first location.                          

                                           THE REJECTIONS                                                  
                  The Examiner relies upon the following as evidence of unpatentability:                   
                   Creekmore                 US 4,187,498                   Feb. 5, 1980                   
                   Braun                     US 4,321,672                 Mar. 23, 1982                    

                                                    2                                                      



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013