Ex Parte Skinner - Page 5

               Appeal No. 2007-0392                                                                   
               Application No. 10/427,733                                                             

                     outer wall 224 thus forming a generally U-shaped channel. . . .                  
                     In one presently preferred embodiment . . . , the inner wall 228,                
                     outer  wall  224,  and  the  membrane  230,  are  formed  as  an                 
                     integral unit relative to each other, thus being unitary in nature               
                     (i.e., monolithically formed as a single unit).                                  
               Page 21 (as amended Jan. 18, 2005, emphasis added).  Thus, the                         
               specification uses the phrase in a manner consistent with the Examiner’s               
               definition.  It does not indicate an intent to give the term a novel meaning.          
                     Therefore, we interpret the claim language “monolithically formed as             
               a single unit” to mean that each arcuate members is formed as a single piece,          
               as opposed to being formed by attachment of two or more separate pieces.               
               This interpretation gives the claim language its broadest reasonable                   
               interpretation consistent with the specification and relies on the usual               
               definition of the terms.                                                               
                     Claim 21 requires the two members to directly engage each other in a             
               manner providing relative rotation between them.  Together, the two                    
               members must form a channel having adjustable curvature.                               
                     Claim 33 requires one curved member to comprise an engagement                    
               member, and the other curved member to comprise an aperture that directly              
               engages the engagement member, providing rotation between the two curved               
               members.  Claim 33 also requires at least one of the curved members to have            
               a breakable notch along its length.                                                    







                                                  5                                                   

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013