Ex Parte Wollenberg et al - Page 9

                Appeal 2007-0511                                                                                 
                Application 10/699,508                                                                           
            1                3.     O’Rear                                                                       
            2          O’Rear discloses a blend of lube base oils which provide improved                         
            3   oxidation stability, both with and without additives.  O’Rear, para. [0001].                     
            4          According to O’Rear, para. [0002]:                                                        
            5                Finished lubricants used for automobiles, diesel engines,                           
            6          and industrial applications consist of two general components:                            
            7          a lube base oil and additives.  In general, a few lube base oils                          
            8          are used to generate a wide variety of finished lubricants by                             
            9          varying the mixtures of individual lube base oils and individual                          
           10          additives.  This requires that lube base oils be stored without                           
           11          additives prior to use.  Also, lube base oils are an item of                              
           12          commerce and are bought, sold and exchanged.  Since the                                   
           13          receiver of the lube base oil wants to formulate specific finished                        
           14          lubes, they do not want to receive lube base oils that already                            
           15          contain additives.  Thus, lube base oils in almost all                                    
           16          circumstances do not contain additives, and are simply                                    
           17          hydrocarbons prepared from petroleum or other sources.  Thus                              
           18          one general requirement for a lube base oil is that it have good                          
           19          stability during shipment and storage in the absence of                                   
           20          additives.  In addition, it is desirable that the finished lubricant                      
           21          have as good a stability as possible.  In this case, the stability is                     
           22          the resistance to oxidation and formation of deposits during                              
           23          shipment and storage in the presence of additives and other                               
           24          compounds that simulate use in commercial equipment.  The                                 
           25          preferred lube base oil is one that has a combination of good                             
           26          stability without additives and with additives.                                           
           27                                                                                                    
           28          The lube base oil disclosed in O’Rear may be used in a finished                           
           29   lubricant composition and, thus, may contain one or more additives,                              
           30   depending on the particular use of the oil.  O’Rear, para. [0046].                               
           31          O’Rear discloses that the additives are used in amounts which are                         
           32   known to those of skill in the art, preferably about 0.1 to about 40 weight                      
           33   percent of the final lube oil product.  O’Rear, para. [0046].                                    


                                                       9                                                         

Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013