Ex Parte Wilson - Page 2

              Appeal 2007-0896                                                                                         
              Application 09/731,019                                                                                   

         1           The Appellant invented a way for users of content on a distributed                                
         2    communication network to collectively indicate the degree of helpfulness or                              
         3    usefulness of individual items of content, such as for example reviews of                                
         4    commercially available products and/or services, usenet postings, news articles,                         
         5    etc., by interactively voting or indicating that particular items of content were                        
         6    helpful or otherwise valuable to the user. Subsequent users then are able to sort                        
         7    retrieved items of content by degree of helpfulness or usefulness according to the                       
         8    number of previous users who have indicated that the individual items of content                         
         9    were helpful or otherwise valuable (Specification 1).  An understanding of the                           
        10    invention can be derived from a reading of exemplary claim 1, which is reproduced                        
        11    below.                                                                                                   
        12           1. A method for identifying as being helpful or otherwise valuable                                
        13           product/service reviews in a database coupled to a distributed                                    
        14           communication network, the method comprising:                                                     
        15           displaying product/service reviews from the database on a client                                  
        16           display connected to the database over the network;                                               
        17           providing an interactive element associated with each of the displayed                            
        18           reviews on the client display, which when clicked by a user, indicates                            
        19           that the user has found a displayed review associated with a                                      
        20           product/service helpful in determining whether or not to purchase or                              
        21           use the product/service;                                                                          
        22           receiving at the database an indication that the user has clicked the                             
        23           interactive element, and incrementing a count of a stored number of                               
        24           indications for the review (1) in response to the indication and (2) if                           
        25           the stored number of indications does not exceed one indication for                               
        26           the review from the user; and                                                                     
        27           displaying the count of the stored number of indications for the review                           
        28           on the client display together with the review.                                                   
        29                                                                                                             


                                                           2                                                           


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013