Ex Parte Askeland et al - Page 8

               Appeal 2007-0960                                                                             
               Application 10/066,529                                                                       
                                                                                                           
               use profiles to provide information useful in controlling printhead                          
               temperature (Smith, col. 1, l. 64 - col. 2, l. 2).                                           
                      In short, the thermistor’s output in Smith (i.e., the signal used to                  
               “closely estimate” the printhead temperature) depends on, among other                        
               things, the ejection history of the ejection elements and whether the ejection               
               elements have been fired.  This detected temperature is inputted to                          
               microprocessor 2 which accounts for these and other factors to control the                   
               printhead temperature.  This controlled temperature, in turn, is detected by                 
               the thermistor and sent to the microprocessor.                                               
                      Even if we assume, without deciding, that Smith’s controller is                       
               configured to estimate the actual printhead temperature solely on the basis                  
               measured temperature of the printhead, that measured temperature, however,                   
               is based at least in part on the other two recited factors--namely, the thermal              
               response model and the ejection history.  That is, both the thermal response                 
               model and the ejection history in Smith are substantial factors in                           
               determining the temperature sensor’s output signal.  As key aspects of                       
               Smith’s temperature control system, the thermal response model and the                       
               ejection history directly contribute to controlling the printhead’s                          
               temperature--and therefore the temperature detected by the sensor.  The                      
               sensor’s output signal, in turn, is used to estimate the temperature to                      
               ultimately control the temperature.                                                          
                      Simply put, estimating the actual temperature of the printhead                        
               assembly in Smith’s temperature feedback control system necessarily is                       
               based at least in part on all three recited factors: (1) the measured or current             
               operating temperature of the printhead assembly; (2) a thermal response                      



                                                     8                                                      

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013