Ex Parte Waldenburg - Page 4

                Appeal 2007-1181                                                                             
                Application 10/513,879                                                                       

                            second reagent is contained in the second compartment.  (Col.                    
                            4, ll. 27-37).                                                                   
                      4) In use, hand pressure is applied to the outside of the second                       
                           compartment to rupture or break the internal seal at the weakened                 
                           portion.  The second reagent then flows toward the test pad and is                
                           absorbed through the absorbent top layer of the test pad to                       
                           activate the first reagent.  The patient then tears open the outer                
                           package on one end to remove the wetted test pad 12 from the                      
                           outer package.   (Col. 4, ll. 54-62).                                             

                                    ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS                                                 
                      Appellant asserts that the claims stand or fall as a single group.  (Br.               
                6).  Therefore, we decide the first ground of rejection on the basis of claim                
                15 and the second ground of rejection on the basis of claim 16, which                        
                depends from claim 15.  37 C.F.R. § 41.37(c)(1)(vii) (2005).                                 
                      Claims 14-15                                                                           
                      The Examiner found that Guadagno discloses the invention as claimed                    
                in claim 15 with the exception of a teaching that the package is evacuated to                
                remove air.  (Answer 4).  The Examiner determined that it would have been                    
                obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art at the time of the invention to                  
                evacuate air in Guadagno’s package upon sealing the layers of the package                    
                together since Guadagno teaches that the package should protect the                          
                reagents held within the package from moisture during storage, and the                       
                removal of air in the package upon formation would remove any moisture                       



                                                     4                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013