Ex Parte Van Cleve et al - Page 6

                Appeal 2007-1604                                                                             
                Application 09/966,064                                                                       
                                                                                                            
                Nakagiri, there would be no need to couple the external peripheral device to                 
                transfer the drivers in Alcorn.  In such a case, the drivers would already be                
                stored in Alcorn’s system (Answer 6-7).                                                      
                      Second, Appellants argue that a ROM device with a particular BIOS                      
                is generally destined for a particular computer.  Therefore, Appellants                      
                contend, the skilled artisan would not think to put BIOS programs for a                      
                particular machine on the same ROM device with hardware drivers for                          
                multiple different operating systems (Br. 16).  The Examiner argues that                     
                storing hardware drivers for multiple different operating systems in the                     
                system ROM would reduce operating system installation time.  According to                    
                the Examiner, the user may only need to update the BIOS, but not need to                     
                spend additional time to install additional drivers for different operating                  
                systems (Answer 7).                                                                          
                      We will sustain the Examiner’s rejection of claim 10.  Alcorn                          
                discloses a microprocessor-based electronic casino gaming system with,                       
                among other things, a system boot ROM 14 that provides the initialization                    
                software required when power is initially applied (Alcorn, col. 6, ll. 24-29;                
                Fig. 1).  As shown in Figure 2, ROM 14 comprises two separate ROM                            
                elements: (1) ROM 29 which contains, among other things, the system                          
                initialization or boot code, and (2) ROM 30 which includes the operating                     
                system program and system drivers (Alcorn, col. 7, ll. 18-32; Fig. 2).   In                  
                another embodiment, Alcorn discloses that ROM 14 comprises (1) ROM 50                        
                (containing the BIOS software), and (2) ROM 52 (containing, among other                      
                things, the boot strap code, operating system code, and operating system                     
                drivers) (Alcorn, col. 9, ll. 38-55; Fig. 6).                                                



                                                     6                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013