Ex Parte McMahon - Page 4

             Appeal 2007-2227                                                                                      
             Application 10/778,963                                                                                
                    the shape or pattern of the spiral regions (30,38) of Cayton for the                           
                    spiral region (162) as shown by Cloud in Figs. 32-34.  One would be                            
                    motivated to make such a combination because one would want to                                 
                    achieve that exact shape or design of spiral region as shown by Cloud                          
                    in addition to the ability of said shape of said spiral region being able                      
                    to be interconnect with another of said spiral region as shown by                              
                    Cloud in Figs. 32-34 creating that exact type of fastening relationship                        
                    between said spiral regions.                                                                   
             (Id.)                                                                                                 
                    The Examiner concludes                                                                         
                    one only needs to modify the structure of both the spiral regions                              
                    (30,38) of Cayton to emulate the spiral region (162) of Cloud to have                          
                    a structure that discloses side by side reverse mirrored spiral regions                        
                    having a decreasing radius for greater than one full revolution, with                          
                    said extension being adapted to join another extension and lay flat                            
                    with respect to each other when joined.                                                        
             (Id.)                                                                                                 
                    Appellant argues neither Cayton nor Cloud teach a pair of reverse image and                    
             side by side spirals that are joined at a center and extend outwardly from opposite                   
             sides of the center.  (Br. 9.)                                                                        













                                                       - 4 -                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013