Ex Parte McMahon - Page 5

             Appeal 2007-2227                                                                                      
             Application 10/778,963                                                                                
                    Appellant’s Fig. 1, which shows a fragmentary perspective view of a                            
             necklace extension in the shape of the letter “S” which represents an embodiment                      
             of the claimed invention (Specification 6), appears above.                                            










                    A portion of Fig. 2 of Cayton, which depicts a necklace extension in the                       
             shape of the letter “S” where the top of the “S” is smaller than the bottom of the                    
             “S,” appears above.                                                                                   










                    Figures 32 to 34 of Cloud, depicting ear ornaments showing mirror image                        
             spirals, appear above.                                                                                
                    More specifically, Appellant argues that “[t]he Cayton hooks have a large                      
             spiral on one side and a small tight loop (connectors 30 and 32) on the other side,”                  
             thus "[i]t is clear from the disclosure that the hooks and chain construction of                      

                                                       - 5 -                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013