Ex Parte 6379190 et al - Page 8

                Appeal 2007-2577                                                                             
                Application 90/006,344                                                                       
                exclude the use of additional elements, such as the small nut 26,18 in affixing              
                the tail portion to the rope light.                                                          

                      tubular conductors                                                                     
                      Prazoff argues that Lin does not show tubular conductors protruding                    
                outwardly from the first member head.19  It is true that Lin does not show                   
                the conductors in sockets 241 protruding beyond the outer surfaces of                        
                socket 24 or connector 25.  Claim 1, however, does not require the tubular                   
                conductors to extend so far.  In understanding this limitation, it is instructive            
                to consider Prazoff's disclosure.  Prazoff discloses a first member head                     
                portion 31 with locking                                                                      
                sockets 33 and tubular                                                                       
                conductors 34.20  A detail                                                                   
                from Prazoff FIG. 3 (right)                                                                  
                shows the structure.  The                                                                    
                detail shows the tubular                                                                     
                conductors 34 projecting in                                                                  
                an outward direction (away                                                                   
                from the first ropelight 10),                                                                
                but not beyond the outer                                                                     
                face of the first member                                                                     
                head portion 31.  Prazoff                                                                    
                has not pointed us to                                                                        
                                                                                                            
                18 Recall that Lin considers the small nut to be part of the connecting socket,              
                so it is really an additional subunit of the same assembly.                                  
                19 Br. 19.                                                                                   
                20 Spec. 3:7-14.                                                                             

                                                     8                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013