Ex Parte Joly et al - Page 2

                Appeal 2007-3363                                                                             
                Application 10/342,711                                                                       
                essentially the same except in the percentage of light absorbed and reflected.               
                We select claim 1 as representative of the claims on appeal.  Claim 1 is                     
                reproduced as it appears in the claim appendix to the Substitute Appeal Brief                
                (Br.) except that it has been indented as required under 37 C.F.R. § 41.75(i):               
                      1. A binderless stimulable phosphor screen comprising                                  
                            a vapor deposited phosphor layer on a support                                    
                      incorporating into the bulk of said support                                            
                            a white pigment and                                                              
                            a pigment absorbing light of a wavelength above 600 nm                           
                                   absorbing at least 30 % of the stimulating light and                      
                                   reflecting at least 60 % of the stimulated light                          
                            wherein said vapor deposited phosphor is a needle-                               
                      shaped phosphor,                                                                       
                                   being a CsX:Eu stimulable phosphor,                                       
                                   wherein x [sic, X] represents a halide selected                           
                      from the group consisting of Br and Cl.                                                
                      We are obligated to construe an application claim as broadly as is                     
                reasonable in view of the specification.  The screen is defined using the                    
                transitional term "comprising", which opens the screen to the inclusion of                   
                elements not listed in the claim.                                                            
                      The phrase "vapor deposited phosphor" is expressly defined to mean                     
                any of thermal-vapor deposition, chemical-vapor deposition, electron-beam                    
                deposition, radio-frequency deposition, and pulsed-laser deposition.                         
                (Specification (Spec.) 4:7-11.)                                                              
                      Agfa prefers supports that are ceramic, glass, or polymer film                         
                (Spec. 4:14-20), but the claim is not limited to these.  Suitable white                      
                pigments include titanium dioxide (TiO2) and barium sulfate (BaSO4)                          
                (Spec. 4:27-30), but the claim is not limited to these.  The specification gives             
                organic and inorganic blue pigments as examples of pigments absorbing                        


                                                     2                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013