Earl G. Higbee and Lesley A. Higbee - Page 11




                                       - 11 -                                         
          See id.                                                                     
               To substantiate additional charitable contributions of                 
          $6,937.20 for 1996 not previously claimed on their return for               
          that year, petitioners offered several documents to the Court.              
          Some of the documents do not have any indication of being                   
          provided by a donee organization but instead appear to have been            
          generated by petitioners.  Other documents consist of preprinted            
          forms issued by alleged charitable organizations which                      
          petitioners filled in with the type and number of items donated             
          and the estimated value of the donation.  In addition,                      
          petitioners submitted checks and receipts which appear to be for            
          the purchase of goods and services.  Lastly, at trial,                      
          petitioners attempted to buttress their claims by describing the            
          types of goods allegedly donated.                                           
               While the preprinted forms appear authentic, we nevertheless           
          conclude that petitioners’ self-generated receipts and other                
          documents are not credible evidence of the order necessary to               
          substantiate the deductions claimed in the instant case.  See               
          Tokh v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2001-45.  Further, we do not               
          find petitioners’ testimony credible.  We hold that petitioners             
          have failed to introduce credible evidence to substantiate the              
          actual items contributed and their fair market values.4  See sec.           

               4  For instance, on one of the preprinted forms, petitioners           
          listed a charitable contribution of $700 for “cribs” and $200 for           
          “baby clothes”.  Because petitioners have failed to establish how           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011