Ex parte GOODMAN et al. - Page 4




         Appeal No. 96-4102                                                         
         Application 08/500,421                                                     


              It is the examiner’s finding of fact, and we concur, that             
         Figure 10 of Arcudi shows a tear-openable package 80.  The                 
         package 80 can contain a flowable material such as a powder.               
         See column 5, line 12.  The package is formed of a tear-resistant          
         material (column 1, line 53) of heat-sealable synthetic resin              
         formed from two sheets of plastic film heat-sealed around the              
         edge 83 for forming the compartment 84 to house the material or            
         drug to be dispensed.  See column 4, lines 49 ff.  As shown in             
         Figure 10, the package or container 80 has four right angle                
         corners.  A slit 17 is cut through the plastic film at an oblique          
         angle to one of the corners, as depicted in Figure 14, so that             
         the lower right-hand corner of Figure 10 may be manually torn              
         away from the remainder of the package thereby forming a pouring           
         opening in the container by which any powder therein might be              
         removed.  As stated above, we concur in the examiner’s findings            
         of fact and with the examiner’s ultimate finding that Arcudi               
         clearly anticipates the subject matter of claim 4.                         
              Appellants argue, on page 7 of the brief, that Arcudi is not          
         a bag.  Appellants continue the argument by relating how the               
         present specification discloses how appellants make a bag from a           
         tube-like web of tear-resistant synthetic resin.  We are in                



                                         4                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007