Ex parte TAYLOR - Page 7




          Appeal No. 97-0974                                                          
          Application No. 08/234,294                                                  


               It is true that the specification does state:                          
               The computer can compute appropriate motor commands                    
               to  move the camera to achieve a desired                               
               relationship with the surgeon's instrument.  The                       
               system can include a method of aligning the                            
               manipulator center of motion to a body part and then                   
               grabbing the part with an adjustable clamp.  In the                    
               simplest case, the computer could simply command                       
               appropriate 2  and 2  commands to place the image ofx     y                                                   
               a single beacon attached to an instrument at any                       
               desired place (e.g. the center) in the video image                     
               seen by the video camera.  This could be done either                   
               in a continuously tracking mode or on command from                     
               the surgeon.  In more complex cases, the computer                      
               would also use the distal 2  and sliding motors to                     
                                          z                                           
               provide a "roll" and "zoom" capability.  [Page 49,                     
               lines 13-28.]                                                          
          It does not follow, however, that just because it is broadly                
          stated (1) the computer can compute appropriate motor commands              
          to move the camera and (2) the computer commands an image to                
          be placed in the center of the video image seen by the camera,              
          that the computer necessarily functions as a "means" for                    
          making an automatic selection of different ones of the sensing              
          modes to be used by the means for sensing (independent claims               
          50 and 74) or a selector for automatically selecting the                    
          sensing mode to be used by the sensor (independent claim 75).               




                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007