Ex parte LIPP - Page 5




          Appeal No. 97-1504                                                          
          Application No. 08/400,190                                                  


               The thrust of the Wagai invention is to improve upon the               
          prior art situation in which the display switch has to be                   
          operated many times in order to display a plurality of stored               
          messages (column 2, line 9 et seq.).  To overcome this                      
          problem, Wagai teaches displaying stored messages either                    
          sequentially by scrolling through them or manually, one at a                
          time.  According to the Wagai method, stored messages are                   
          sequentially presented in a scrolling manner so long as the                 
          user depresses (activates) and holds switch 11.  When the                   
          switch is released, the scrolling stops and a single message                
          is displayed.  Another message is manually displayed if switch              
          11 is momentarily activated.  See column 7, line 26 et seq.                 
          This is essentially the opposite of the method recited in the               
          appellant’s claims.  Wagai does not disclose or teach a method              
          wherein a free-running display of stored messages is initiated              
          by the receipt of a user input signal to a multiple function                
          switch without further receipt of a user input signal, and                  
          wherein said free-running display is terminated and a manual                
          display mode initiated upon receipt of a subsequent user input              
          signal.  In other words, wherein the appellant’s invention is               


                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007