Ex parte GROSS - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-1380                                                          
          Application 08/219,189                                                      


          claims separate consideration.  37 CFR § 1.192(c)(7).                       
          Instead, the brief merely asserts that whereas the claims of                
          the first group are broad enough to read on a transfer member               
          in the form of an intermediate transfer member, the claims of               
          the second group are directed to transfer members in the form               
          of bias transfer rolls and transport belts.  "Merely pointing               
          out differences in what the claims cover is not an argument as              
          to why the claims are separately patentable."  Id.                          
          Consequently, all of the appealed claims will be treated as                 
          standing or falling with claim 14, the broadest claim, which                
          reads as follows.                                                           
               14.  A transfer apparatus in which residual material on a              
          transfer member is removed to a photoconductive member,                     
          comprising:                                                                 
               a blade, movable between a first position, contacting the              
          transfer member, and a second position, spaced from the                     
          transfer member, said blade accumulating residual material in               
          the first position; and                                                     
               a biasing device associated with the transfer member, for              
          selectively applying to the transfer member a bias of a first               
          polarity or a bias of a second polarity, opposite to the first              
          polarity, said blade being in the first position in response                
          to said biasing device applying the bias of the first                       
          polarity, and the biasing device applying the bias of the                   
          second polarity in response to the blade being in the second                
          position as to attract the accumulated residual material to                 
          the photoconductive member.                                                 

                                        - 6 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007