Ex parte TAKAHASHI et al. - Page 5




               Appeal No. 96-1727                                                                                                  
               Application 08/130,575                                                                                              



               the claimed encoder means may comprise the color palette circuit 12 which encodes for                               
               color presentation bit data supplied to it from the VRAM 4 to form display signals to be                            
               imparted to the CRT 5, which unit again displays the data in the claimed "units of                                  
               predetermined rasters."                                                                                             
                       The Figure 20 version, as principally relied upon by the examiner, may additionally                         
               be construed to teach that the VRAM 4 and the extended VRAM memory 80 may                                           
               comprise the display side memory.  The claimed processor side memory of claim 1 is not                              
               recited in such a manner as to exclude the external supply memory 3 as comprising this                              
               memory for purposes of this claim.  It is further noted that with respect to the admitted prior                     
               art discussion of Figures 1 and 2 as discussed at the top of column 2 of Nishi, it was                              
               known in the art that the VRAM may also be extended by an additional memory device in                               
               the manner depicted with respect to Figure 20.                                                                      
                       As to claim 4, the original memory 3 in the Figure 3 version of the embodiments in                          
               Nishi reads upon the claimed external storage means of the preamble of claim 4 and the                              
               CRT 5 remains the display monitor means of this claim.  The first memory means                                      
               comprises alternatively the VRAM 4 and the extended VRAM memory 80 of the Figure 20                                 
               embodiment whereas these same memories, because of their functional usages with                                     
               respect to the Figure 20 embodiment, also may be construed to comprise the second                                   
               memory means claimed.  The VRAMs 4 and 80 clearly are taught to buffer image data                                   

                                                                5                                                                  





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007