SAWADA et al. V. JIN et al. - Page 19




          Interference No. 103,141                                                    



          However, this does not extend to including two patentably                   
          distinct inventions in one interference count.                              
                    We have reviewed the denial of Sawada’s motion 1                  
          anew, giving no deference to the decision in the APJ’s                      
          interlocutory order.  We have reached the independent                       
          conclusion that the motion was correctly decided.  The motion               
          stands properly DENIED.                                                     
               The Failure of the APJ to Accord Benefit to Sawada with                
             Respect to Japanese Application No. 62-25224 as to Proposed              
                                       Count A                                        
                    As noted above, Sawada Motion 1 to add proposed                   
          count A to the interference was properly denied.                            
          Consequently, it could                                                      




          not have been improper for the APJ to deny Sawada benefit as                
          to a count never added to the interference.                                 
             The denial of Sawada Preliminary Motion 15 to Accord Sawada              
            Benefit of Japanese Application No. 62-25224 as to New Count              
                                         3;                                           
                    After Judge Smith redeclared the interference adding              
          counts 2 and 3, Sawada filed Motion No. 15 pursuant to 37 CFR               


                                         19                                           





Page:  Previous  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007