Ex parte MANZ et al. - Page 5




         Appeal No. 1997-3328                                                    
         Application No. 08/226,605                                              


         THE INVENTION PORTION provides "[i]t is therefore an object of          
         the present invention to provide a method for controlling               
         sample introduction in microcolumn separation techniques ...            
         which overcomes the disadvantages of the prior art"                     
         (specification, pages 2-3).                                             




              The step of assuring that "the composition of the sample           
         in the sample volume 27 reflects the actual composition in the          
         reservoir" is described, at least in part, in terms of                  
         parameters for calculating the minimum time the electric                
         potential is applied across the supply and drain channels               
         (specification, page 7).                                                
              The examiner's rejection of claim 19 states "[c]laim 19            
         is rejected for reasons already given in the office action              
         mailed May 16, 1995" (final, page 2).4  The examiner explained          
         that "Verheggen teaches separating the sample using the same            

                                                                                
              4 The final rejection (Paper No. 6) rejects claim 19 by reference to
         "the office action mailed May 16, 1995" for an explanation of the rejection.
         We interpret the May 16, 1995 rejection of claim 1 as the basis for rejection
         of claim 19 (claim 1 was replaced by claim 19 pursuant to the amendment filed
         August 22, 1995, Paper No. 5).                                          

                                        5                                        





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007