Ex parte JOFFE - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1999-1779                                                        
          Application No. 08/480,561                                                  


          of elements 112 and 14', and therefore the direction                        
          transverse to the drive direction is parallel to the planes of              
          the aforementioned facing surfaces.                                         
               Bardocz is directed to a system which allows precision                 
          alignment of a linearly translatable element (Z) with respect               
          to a platform element (R).  Bardocz discloses a lower element               
          (V)  and an upper element (Z).  Each element has a surface                  
          that faces the other, and interposed between the two elements               
          are a plurality of balls mounted in grooves in the opposed                  
          surfaces.  The elements are held together by magnetic force.                
          By means of inputs applied by a coarse adjustment drive (T)                 
          and a fine adjustment drive (M), the upper element is                       
          positionable transversely with respect to the lower element.                
          Considering that the “drive direction” in the appellant’s                   
          claim 1 is perpendicular to the facing surfaces, the Bardocz                
          mechanism causes the elements to move relative to one another               
          along a “direction transverse to the drive direction,” in the               
          language of claim 1.                                                        
               However, Bardocz fails to disclose some of the other                   
          features of claim 1.  Looking to the specific language of                   
          claim 1, Bardocz is not disclosed as a “bearing,” much less a               
                                         11                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007