Ex parte JOFFE - Page 12




          Appeal No. 1999-1779                                                        
          Application No. 08/480,561                                                  


          bearing for applying force from a driving mover to move a                   
          driven object along a drive direction, that is, a direction                 
          perpendicular to the planes of the facing surfaces of the two               
          elements.  Nor is one of the elements “freely” movable with                 
          respect to the other, as evidenced by the presence of the two               
          adjustment screw means that engage (as T) or are attached (as               
          M) to the elements, thus fixing them together.  In addition,                
          there is no disclosure in Bardocz of moving the two elements                
          in the “drive direction,” nor is there reason to conclude that              
          such movement is inherent.  Thus, as might be expected,                     
          Bardocz fails to disclose a driving mover and a driven object               
          which interact with the two elements, or the “means for                     
          receiving driving contact from the driving mover at the                     
          driving bearing element” and “means for applying driving                    
          contact from the driven bearing element to the driven object.”              
                                                                                     
               This being the case, Bardocz does not anticipate the                   
          subject matter of claim 1, and we will not sustain this                     
          rejection of claim 1 or of claims 2-7, which depend therefrom.              


               Independent claim 19 also is directed to a wobble-                     
                                         12                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007