Ex Parte WATERS - Page 5

            Appeal No. 2000-1349                                                      
            Application No. 08/475,026                                                

                 In Giladi’s illustrated embodiment, the vehicle                      
            appears to be in the form of an attachment to a tractor.                  
            However, in column 1, lines 53-58, Giladi expressly                       
            recognizes that as an alternative to the attachment                       
            embodiment, the illustrated apparatus may be a part of the                
            self-propelled tractor itself.  Tractors of the type                      
            disclosed in the Giladi patent conventionally have frames                 
            for mounting the various component parts of the vehicle.                  
                 Based on the foregoing analysis, claim 15 differs from               
            Giladi by reciting the means for moving each platform in a                
            pure vertical direction, by reciting the means for moving                 
            each platform in a pure horizontal direction perpendicular                
            to the long axis of the frame and by reciting that the                    
            platforms are connected to a mid-portion of the frame.                    
            Similarly, claim 1 differs from Giladi by reciting the                    
            means for moving each platform purely vertically and purely               
            horizontally perpendicularly to the frame’s long axis, and                
            by further reciting that the platforms are located on a                   
            mid-portion of the frame.                                                 
                 Giladi also lacks an express teaching of mounting the                
            platforms and their adjusting structures on the frame of                  
            the tractor.  However, such teaching is implicit in                       
            Giladi’s disclosure to support the substantial loads                      

                                          5                                           


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007