Ex Parte WOOD et al - Page 10



          Appeal No. 2004-0024                                                           
          Application No. 09/249,922                                   Page 10           

          33).  By using a specially programmed microprocessor, the voltage              
          and current supply to the lamp can be controlled in many steps                 
          between turn on and normal running conditions (col. 7,                         
          lines 4-9).  In addition, the controller can also measure lamp                 
          light output, its color temperature, and its actual temperature                
          (col. 7, lines 39-45).                                                         
               Gaus is directed to a metal halide arc discharge lamp (col.               
          1, lines 6 and 7).  As stated by the examiner (answer, page 5)                 
          gas discharge and metal halide lamps are known in the art as high              
          intensity discharge lamps.  Although Gaus does not disclose the                
          metal halide arc discharge lamp to be a HID, we take Notice3 that              
          high-intensity discharge (HID) is a term denoting a general group              
          of lamps consisting of mercury, metal halide and high-pressure                 
          sodium lamps.  A mercury lamp is an electric discharge lamp.                   
          Metal halide lamps are very similar in construction to the                     
          mercury lamps, the major difference being the addition of a metal              
          halide in the arc tube.  Because the metal halide lamp of Gaus                 
          and the gas discharge lamp of Cockram are both HIDs and are very               
          similar in construction, we consider the references to be of                   
          analogous art, and find that an artisan would have been motivated              

               3 Standard Handbook for Electrical Engineers, ©1993 McGraw-Hill, Inc.,    
          Chapter 26, pps 31-36; a copy of which is attached to the Decision.            





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007