Ex Parte Goldstein - Page 27



           Appeal No. 2005-0823                                                                        
           Application No. 10/300,895                                             Page 27              


            Because this disclosure is listed as being "traditional," we find                          
            it to represent admitted prior art.                                                        
                  This evidence supplements our findings, as the evidence                              
            makes clear that while travel agents traditionally reported sales                          
            weekly, they consistently offered their customers the courtesy of                          
            voiding airline tickets issued in a given week, without reporting                          
            the original sale to the airlines.                                                         
                  Turning to the Declaration under 37 CFR § 1.132 of Ms.                               
            Vivian Pommier, dated October 13, 2003, we find from the                                   
            Declaration that travel agencies conduct transactions according                            
            to the IAH, which is prepared and distributed by ARC.  As stated                           
            on page 2, reporting of issued ticket to the airlines happened on                          
            a weekly batch basis, and that even though the data for the                                
            ticket sales was sent daily to ARC, that ARC did not report the                            
            issuances to the airlines until the end of the weekly reporting                            
            period.  Travel agents could, up until the end of the weekly                               
            reporting period, make changes to a ticket without collecting any                          
            airline-imposed change fees.  The Declaration additionally states                          
            that under this practice, which was in place until June of 2003,                           
            a ticket sale was essentially non-permanent until the end of the                           
            weekly reporting period.  In November of 2003, ARC notified                                






Page:  Previous  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007