Ex Parte Monteverde - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2006-2563                                                        
          Application No. 09/624,107                                                  
          (col. 1, lines 62-66; col. 7, lines 12-20).  If a user who has              
          clicked on a merchant’s link on an associate’s web site purchases           
          a product from the merchant’s web site, the merchant’s software             
          automatically credits the associate by, for example, crediting a            
          commission to the associate’s account (col. 2, lines 9-14).  The            
          merchant’s link on the associate’s web site can include a search            
          term (e.g., “Terrain Skiing”) chosen by the associate (col. 12,             
          lines 10-14; fig. 6).1                                                      
               The examiner acknowledges that Davis does not disclose                 
          providing in a first selectable link a term chosen by an                    
          advertiser associate or an advertiser associate’s web site                  
          (answer, 20th page).2  The examiner’s reason for combining Davis            
          and Bezos is in a single, page and a half long sentence (answer,            
          23rd to 25th pages).  That sentence sets forth what the examiner            
          asserts one of ordinary skill in the art would have been                    
          motivated to do, e.g., “to have a user or customer visit an                 
          advertiser’s associate web site and seamlessly click on a                   
          referral link or a graphical icon or keyword associated with a              
          plurality of objects or advertisers’ links and displayed thereon,           
          without the user’s input or search query and based on the                   
                                                                                     
          1 Selecting the associate’s link sends the user to the merchant’s web page. 
          That selection does not display on the user’s computer the plurality of     
          advertiser links required by the appellant’s independent claims, and there is
          no evidence that the merchant would want a plurality of advertiser links    
          displayed on the merchant’s web page.                                       
                                          4                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013