Ex Parte Stieber et al - Page 9

             Appeal Number: 2006-2607                                                                               
             Application Number: 10/004,738                                                                         

         1   not render claim 15 or the claims depending therefrom indefinite.  Accordingly, we                     
         2   do not sustain the Examiner's rejection of claims 2-9 and 15-21 under 35 U.S.C.                        
         3   § 112, second paragraph, as rendering the claimed subject matter indefinite.                           
         4                                                                                                          
         5     Claims 2-9 and 15-21 rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a) as obvious over Amos,                         
         6                                 Watanabe, and Richardson.                                                
         7       As regards independent claim 15, the above facts show that Amos describes a                        
         8   cash management system; a first cash handling device for processing notes                              
         9   including sorting of notes, totaling of notes received, and communicating note                         
        10   totals to at least one of: a second cash handling device, a visual display and                         
        11   communication  through a network, wherein said first cash handling device does                         
        12   not have the capability to receive or dispense coins (the note accepting/distributing                  
        13   machine in one ATM); a second cash handling device for processing coins                                
        14   including sorting of coins, totaling of coins received, and communicating coin                         
        15   totals to at least one of: the first cash handling machine, a visual display and a                     
        16   network, wherein said second cash handling device does not have the capability to                      
        17   receive or dispense notes (the coin accepting/distributing machine in another                          
        18   ATM); and wherein said first cash handling device and said second cash handling                        
        19   device have respective circuits for communicating through a first wireless                             
        20   communication network (satellite communication) wherein the first cash handling                        
        21   device and the second cash handling device provide a cooperative cash                                  
        22   management system in which the totals for notes and coins, respectively, are                           
        23   brought together through wireless communication from these respective devices                          
        24   and are displayed on at least one of the first cash handling device, the second cash                   


                                                         9                                                          


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013