Ex Parte Seul - Page 13

                  Appeal 2007-1624                                                                                         
                  Application 10/424,662                                                                                   
                  27.  The target DNA is denatured and binding to the complementary ONP is                                 
                  performed (Drmanac, col. 18, ll. 49-58); skilled persons in the art would                                
                  have recognized that denaturation of the DNA produces single-stranded                                    
                  DNA.                                                                                                     
                  28.  A single hybridization area can be subdivided into “submatrices”                                    
                  (Drmanac, col. 19, ll. 40 to col. 20, l. 1) in which the particles carry a                               
                  physical or chemical entity which enables recognition of the particle type                               
                  (Drmanac, col. 21, ll. 9-27).  HA replicas (where the particles have the same                            
                  position in each replica) can be utilized (Drmanac, col. 20, ll. 1-3).                                   

                  Application of Drmanac to claims                                                                         
                  29.  Drmanac describes “differing oligonucleotides . . . attached to different                           
                  particles” as recited in claims 76 and 77 (FF 14, 15, and 17).                                           
                  30.  The particles are arranged in a monolayer (FF 20, 21), satisfying the                               
                  limitation in claims 76 and 77 that the particles are in a “planar                                       
                  configuration.”                                                                                          
                  31.  The particles are attached to specific regions of the hybridization area                            
                  (FF 28) and the exact position of each discrete particle in the hybridization                            
                  area can be established (FF 24, 25).  Thus, the particles are on a “defined                              
                  area of a substrate” as recited in claims 76 and 105.                                                    
                  32. The particles described by Drmanac can be labeled with physical                                      
                  attributes or oligonucleotides (i.e., a “chemical characteristic”)(FF 23),                               
                  meeting the limitation recited in claims 76 and 77 that the “particles are                               
                  encoded with a chemical or physical characteristic” that enables their                                   
                  identification.                                                                                          



                                                            13                                                             

Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013