Ex Parte Seul - Page 15

                  Appeal 2007-1624                                                                                         
                  Application 10/424,662                                                                                   
                  41.  The particles can be labeled with oligonucleotides to facilitate their                              
                  recognition (FF 23).  An oligonucleotide is a “chemical tag” and thus meets                              
                  the requirement of claim 84.                                                                             
                  42.  Oligonucleotides can be labeled with visible markers (see, e.g.,                                    
                  Drmanac, at col. 21, ll. 23-25) which are “capable of being interrogated                                 
                  optically” as recited in claim 85.                                                                       
                  43.  The genomic DNA or oligonucleotides of Drmanac hybridize to their                                   
                  complement (FF 27), meeting the limitation of claim 88.                                                  
                  44.  Claim 89 further recites that the claimed array comprises “a multiplicity                           
                  of subarrays of oligonucleotides, wherein the location of each subarray on                               
                  said substrate in combination with the encoding indicates the types of                                   
                  oligonucleotides located therein.”  This limitation is met by Drmanac’s                                  
                  disclosure of HA submatrices, including replica HA in which the particles                                
                  have the same position in each replica (FF 28).                                                          
                  Claim 90                                                                                                 
                  45.  Claim 90 is a product-by-process claim for producing an array of                                    
                  oligonucleotides by steps of: 1) providing reservoirs comprising particles                               
                  having attached oligonucleotides and 2) transferring the particles to a                                  
                  substrate to form a planar array where the particles are in known positions.                             
                  46.  The claim recites that the particles have different oligonucleotides                                
                  attached to them and are “encoded with a chemical or physical characteristic                             
                  that uniquely identifies the particle type and oligonucleotide attached                                  
                  thereto.”                                                                                                
                  47.  The claim also requires that “the known positions of the reservoirs                                 
                  within the layout in combination with the encoding indicate the types of                                 
                  particles contained therein.”  Thus, when the process is carried out, the                                

                                                            15                                                             

Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013