Ex Parte Brandenberger et al - Page 7

                Appeal 2007-1652                                                                                
                Application 09/776,058                                                                          
                                                                                                               
                114 that includes a display screen 140.  Image frames are transferred from                      
                the imaging device 100 to the computer 112 for processing, storage, and                         
                display on the hardware user interface 114 (Anderson, col. 4, ll. 4-30; Fig.                    
                1).                                                                                             
                       In Anderson, the user can create a slideshow by navigating to a                          
                selected media object (e.g., image) and marking the object.  Significantly,                     
                each media object can also be selectively edited before or after incorporation                  
                into the slideshow using the appropriate editor (Anderson, col. 8, l. 66 – col.                 
                9, l. 18; col. 13, ll. 45-48).                                                                  
                       For example, images can be edited using image editing screen 420.                        
                As shown in Figure 12, the user can select a desired image editing function                     
                (“Contrast,” “Brightness,” “Color,” and “Sharpen”) by moving the target                         
                cursor to the item and selecting the “Choose” softkey 206a.  In response, a                     
                menu or screen is displayed that shows modifiable parameters for the                            
                selected item.  In addition, the editing screen displays a thumbnail image of                   
                the selected image 422 and a preview of the modified image 424 (Anderson,                       
                col. 13, l. 59 – col. 14, l. 4; Fig. 12).                                                       
                       We find this selectable image editing functionality in Anderson fully                    
                meets an input device configured to respond to a manual input selecting one                     
                of multiple image filters as claimed.  That is, each image editing function                     
                listed in the menu 402 provides, in effect, a selectable filtering effect (i.e., a              
                selectable “image filter” as claimed) since the function effectively modifies                   
                the image’s appearance in accordance with the selected function.  In fact,                      
                two of Anderson’s editing functions (“Color” and “Sharpen”) are                                 
                commensurate with filtering effects discussed in Appellants’ own                                



                                                       7                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013