Ex Parte Park et al - Page 12



                Appeal 2007-2140                                                                                   
                Application 09/892,790                                                                             
                Patent 5,917,679                                                                                   

                       26. The Examiner based the rejection of claims 21, 30-32 and 41 on                          
                the grounds that pads 108 and 120 of Nepela’s Figure 5c anticipate the                             
                claims.                                                                                            
                       27. The Examiner’s reasoning is found at pages 5-9 of the March 1,                          
                2007 Supplemental Answer.                                                                          

                                                   E.  Nepala                                                      
                       28. Nepela teaches at col. 2, ll. 41-50:                                                    
                       The negative pressure air bearing slider has two side rails                                 
                       providing air bearing surfaces extending fully from the leading                             
                       edge towards the trailing edge of the slider, and a central pad at                          
                       the leading edge for providing an additional air bearing surface.                           
                       Relief vents are formed between the two side rails and the                                  
                       central pad and extend from the slider leading edge to connect                              
                       to a central recessed cavity that extends from the central pad to                           
                       the trailing edge of the slider. The central recessed cavity                                
                       defines an effective negative pressure region.                                              
                       29. Thus Nepela describes “a central pad at the leading edge for                            
                providing an additional air bearing surface,” “a central recessed cavity that                      
                extends from the central pad to the trailing edge of the slider,” and “[the]                       
                central recessed cavity defines an effective negative pressure region.”                            







                                                      - 12 -                                                       

Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013