Ex Parte Park et al - Page 15



                Appeal 2007-2140                                                                                   
                Application 09/892,790                                                                             
                Patent 5,917,679                                                                                   

                       Ogishima  US 4,553,184 Nov. 12, 1985                                                        
                       Mo   US 4,636,894  Jan. 13, 1987                                                            
                       Strom  [I]  US 4,802,042 Jan. 31, 1989                                                      
                       Strom  [II]  US 5,062,017 Oct. 29, 1991                                                     
                       Chapin  US 5,210,666 May 11, 1993                                                           
                       Murray [I]  US 5,353,180 Oct. 4, 1994                                                       
                       Murray [II]  US 5,406,432 Apr. 11, 1995                                                     
                       Dorius  US 5,438,467 Aug. 1, 1995                                                           
                       Bolasna [I]  US 5,650,893 Jul. 22, 1997                                                     
                       Ruiz   US 5,734,524 Mar. 31, 1998                                                           
                       Lairson  US 5,822,153 Oct. 13, 1998                                                         
                       Chhabra  US 5,831,791 Nov. 3, 1998                                                          
                       Bolasna [II]  US 5,870,250 Feb. 9, 1999                                                     
                       Chang  US 5,889,634 Mar. 30, 1999                                                           
                       40. Ogishima, Mo, Strom I, Strom II, Chapin, Murray I, Murray II,                           
                and Dorius are prior art vis-à-vis applicants under 35 U.S.C. § 102 (b).                           
                       41. Bolasna I, Ruiz, Lairson, Chhabra, Bolasna II, and Chang are                            
                prior art vis-à-vis applicants under 35 U.S.C. § 102 (e).                                          

                                                    Ogishima                                                       
                       42. Ogishima describes at figure 2 and the corresponding section                            
                of the Specification (col. 3, l. 59, through col. 4, l. 23) a slider 20 with a                     
                U-shaped air bearing platform formed by surface 27b (cross rail) and the                           
                connected portions of surfaces 26a and 26b (side wall portions) terminating                        
                at grooves 28 and 29 (not coinciding with the rear edge of surface 27a).                           
                Also, surface 27a forms a rear air bearing platform centered on the                                
                longitudinal axis with a magnetic head core 19 (transducer).                                       
                       43. Reissue claims 21, 30-32, and 41 are anticipated by Ogishima.                           

                                                      - 15 -                                                       

Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013