Ex Parte Park et al - Page 18



                Appeal 2007-2140                                                                                   
                Application 09/892,790                                                                             
                Patent 5,917,679                                                                                   

                       55. Reissue claims 21-23, 30-34, and 41 are anticipated by Chang.                           
                                                   Bolasna II                                                      
                       56. Bolasna II describes at figure 19 and the corresponding section                         
                of the Specification (col. 9, l. 49, through col. 10, l. 14) a slider 1100 with a                  
                U-shaped air bearing platform (side rails 1106 and 1108, and crossbar 1130)                        
                whose side wall portions terminate before reaching the rear edge.  The                             
                U-shaped air bearing platform includes an off-center gap (gaps 1150 and                            
                1152).  Also shown is a rear air bearing platform (broadened area 1124)                            
                centered on the longitudinal axis for mounting a transducer.                                       
                       57. Reissue claims 21, 22, 24, 30-33, 35, and 41 are anticipated by                         
                Bolasna II.                                                                                        
                                                     Chapin                                                        
                       58. Chapin describes at figure 2 and the corresponding section                              
                of the Specification (col. 3, l. 34 through col. 4, l. 26) a slider 26 with an                     
                U-shaped air bearing platform formed by cross rail 44 and side rails 40 and                        
                42.  Cross rail 44 is between rails 40 and 42 (col. 3, ll. 54-55) and includes                     
                notch 54 (recessed step) instead of a gap.  The notch is shown as being                            
                centered with respect to the longitudinal axis.                                                    
                                                   Murray  II                                                      
                       59. Murray II describes at figures 4 and 5 and the corresponding                            
                section of the Specification (col. 3, l. 67, through col. 4, l. 31) a slider 11                    
                with a U-shaped air bearing platform formed by the left portion (as seen in                        

                                                      - 18 -                                                       

Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013